News & Views item - March 2007

 

 

The Efficacy of Ethanol as a Petrol Substitute. (March 10, 2007)

    The American Physical Society's Bob Park has the following paragraph in his What's New column this week:

ENERGY: YOU SHOULD WORRY ABOUT WHAT BUSH IS DOING IN BRAZIL.

Even as Roy Masters was talking about generating energy from gravity [at the March APS meeting in Denver], George W. Bush was cutting a deal with President Luiz Ignacio Lula da Silva of Brazil to use ethanol. It made about as much sense. We've been through this before: Brazil makes ethanol from sugar cane. We grown corn. Corn is food. The diversion of food to fuel, even at today's trivial level, has already inflated the price of corn in Mexico, sending Mexicans north for better paying jobs. Toxic waste from fermentation of sugar cane is dumped in the Amazon. We don't have an Amazon. Because the energy balance is precarious, sugar cane must be harvested in Brazil by hand. That condemns vast numbers of laborers to serfdom. We don't have serfs - yet. What we do have is lots of people who are capable of running the numbers for the President to see if ethanol is any kind of a solution. None of these people seem to be in the White House.